Previous Game:
May 16, 2023
Rays 8, Mets 5
2023 Regular Season Game 44
May 17, 2023
Mets 8, Rays 7
Next Game:
May 18, 2023
Mets 3, Rays 2
Click to view scorecard

Box Score Game Memories Scorecard Mets Stats
Thru This Game

METS FANS SHARE THEIR MEMORIES OF THE MAY 17, 2023 GAME:

NYB Buff
May 20, 2023
A three-run homer by Pete Alonso in the bottom of the tenth inning won this game for the Mets. It gave Pete walk-off home runs in each of four consecutive seasons. Only Kevin McReynolds from 1988 to 1991 had done this previously.

Hot Foot
May 20, 2023
An instant classic. Since the Mets have only won the World Series once in my lifetime, to me, everything about that season is enhanced. To me, it's difficult to remember great individual games in seasons other than 1986. This is because if the Mets don't win the World Series, then those great individual games (from let's say 2005, 2006, 2014, or even 2022) tend to fade into the past and be forgotten more quickly. The reason I remember more games from 1986 than 2006 because most of my 2006 memories got flushed down the toilet that October in Game Seven of the NLCS, whereas the 1986 season will always stand out as a "Tiffany" season (in the spirit of the glossy version of Topps baseball cards) and the 2006 season (and every other season that did not result in a World Series win) is just a regular old common Topps set.

As of this writing, I do not know if the Mets will win the World Series this year, but if they do, this game will go down as one of the greatest games in Mets history, an all-time "Tiffany" game. However, if they falter in October, collapse in September, or lay down in August, this will just be another great game that becomes a minor positive note in an otherwise lost season.

Starting with Kodai Senga, he had Jacob deGrom-like stuff, striking out 12 in six innings, the most strikeouts by a Mets rookie since Noah Syndergaard in 2015. On this night, Senga looked like a number one starter, a mini-deGrominator (he's three inches shorter) and he left the game losing 1-0.

In the top of the 7th, Mets radio announcer Keith Raad invoked the announcer jinx when said something along the lines of the Mets are guaranteed a scoreless inning when Jeff Brigham pitches, and on the next pitch the Tampa Bay batter hit a home run against Brigham to make it 2-0.

Then the big moments. Vientos, in his first game of the year, hit a home run in the bottom of the seventh to make it 2-1.

In the bottom of the ninth, with the score 5-2 for the bad, Vogelbach and Marte got on with no out, bringing up Vientos, Baty, and Alvarez. I was sure the kids were going to do it. I wondered, can Vientos do it again?, but he flew out to center. Then Baty struck out, bringing up the man, the legend, the natural, Frankie Alvz. With two outs, Alvarez hit a three run homer, stepping up big time in the clutch to tie the game 5-5.

After Robertson uncharacteristically gave up two runs in the top of the 10th to make it 7-5, McNeil singled leading off the bottom of the tenth, putting two men on base, since the inning had started with a runner on second. After Lindor struck out, Pete Alonso came to the plate. The fans were chanting PETE ALONSO! PETE ALONSO! and on an 0-1 pitch Pete hit a three run homer that turned this game from a possible bitter loss into possibly one of the all-time great Mets wins (in the regular season).

In the Associated Press recap of the game, the writer stated:

A tying two-run homer in the seventh by Mark Vientos, brought up from the minors for his season debut, was only the third-most memorable long ball of the night.

They couldn't have been more accurate. The article also included this quote by Vientos:

“Go! Go! Go! Go!” Vientos remembered telling the ball. “Maybe it listened to me. Maybe it didn't. But who knows?”

This quote made me think, a rookie who talks to baseballs? This guy sounds like an all-star.

This thrilling game is currently in contention for one of the greatest Mets games of all time, contingent on making the postseason and winning the World Series. If they do win it all this year, then Mets fans can look back on this game and know that it all started here.

NYB Buff
June 2, 2023
About my earlier comment on this game, I just want to clarify that Pete Alonso was the second METS player after Kevin McReynolds to hit a walk-off home run in four straight years. I wasn't referring to all major leaguers. Pete's game-winner in the tenth inning also made him the sixth player to share the team record of four career walk-off homers. In addition to Alonso and McReynolds, the others to accomplish this feat with the Mets were Cleon Jones, Chris Jones, Mike Piazza, and Wilmer Flores.



Now it's your turn! Tell us what you remember of this game:

Please note:
We're looking for your comments about this specific game. We've had people use this space to share their thoughts on how the current season is going, or on ways that the Mets can improve the team. Such comments, unless in the context of this particular game, will be considered off-topic and will be removed.

Example One
The Mets suck! They need to trade Smith and get somebody like Jones.
This comment is off-topic and will be removed. It has nothing to do with any specific game. But here's an acceptable alternative:

Example Two
The Mets suck! Smith made three errors in this game, and hit into a double play, and the Mets blew a 5-0 lead. They need to get rid of Smith and get somebody like Jones.
See the difference? Here you're getting the same point across, but it's in the proper context. We wouldn't consider this message to be off-topic, and we would let it remain.

We do appreciate anybody who takes the time to share their thoughts on our site, and we hate to remove anybody's postings. But if we didn't take steps to ensure that only on-topic messages were retained, The Ultimate Mets Database would become a confusing jumble of unrelated comments, and would thus be less enjoyable to visitors like you.

Thank you!



Your name:
E-Mail address:
OPTIONAL
Comments about the game:


Newspaper covers for this game
ROOKS TO KINGS

ROOKS TO KINGS

Newsday
May 18, 2023
A RAY OF HOPE!

A RAY OF HOPE!

New York Daily News
May 18, 2023
BOOM! BOOM! BOOM!

BOOM! BOOM! BOOM!

New York Post
May 18, 2023




About Us
  • Contact us
  • FAQ



  • Copyright 1999-2024, The Ultimate Mets Database